Insurance Agency in Middletown New York
Welcome to Curabba Insurance Agency
Located in Middletown, and serving all of New York. If you're looking for a better insurance experience, we'd love the opportunity to assist with your personal or business insurance needs.
Recognized as a Big I and Reagan Consulting Best Practices Agency for the EIGHTH year in a row
The Curabba Agency has once again been recognized as a Best Practices Agency for 2026, earning a place among an exclusive group of independent insurance agencies nationwide.
The Best Practices Agency designation is awarded to participants in the Best Practices Study, a comprehensive analysis of the business operations and performance of the insurance industry's top-performing independent agencies.
More than 1,190 independent insurance agencies across the United States were nominated during this study cycle. For the 2026 study year, only 300 agencies qualified for and maintained their Best Practices Agency designation.
Since 1993, the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (IIABA or the Big “I”) and Reagan Consulting, an Atlanta-based management consulting firm, have partnered to identify and benchmark the nation's leading independent insurance agencies across seven revenue categories.
Agencies are selected as Best Practices Agencies every three years through a highly competitive nomination and qualification process. To earn the designation, each agency must rank among the top performers within its respective revenue category.
To maintain their Best Practices status throughout the three-year study cycle, participating agencies submit detailed financial and operational information for annual review. The 2026 study year marks the second year of the current three-year cycle.
THE CURABBA DIFFERENCE
Unparalleled Support
When you purchase your insurance from an independent agent like Curabba Insurance, you're getting personalized, but more importantly, unbiased advise. When it comes to protecting your family or business, that is critical.
What's more, after the sale our team will be here for you when you need us. The same cannot be said for many online companies. At Curabba, we take customer service seriously, and we're here to help service you, your family, and your business.
Many people are skeptical when it comes to buying insurance.
We understand the reluctance surrounding the insurance buying process, which is why our process focuses on:
"We can save you time, aggravation, and money. Working on your behalf, we quote through multiple insurance companies, comparing your current coverage with a wide range of insurance carriers to determine the best deal for you."
We have a Simple 3-Step Proces to engage with us
/01
Start a Quote
Provides just enough information to assign you a personal agent
/02
Create a Plan
Our agent will help design your insurance program.
/03
Get Better Results
We demonstrate the results of our process.